Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Charlie Becker's avatar

I’ve never been able to pinpoint why Europe is not appealing to me until reading this: “There’s a cluster of traits I have started to associate with European cities in general, which also applies to London, something like: cultivated, coherent, well-ordered, self-assured, clean, calm, easeful, reliable, downcast, old.”

I live in the US but have lived in Latin America and Asia before. When people find out I lived abroad and like to travel, many Americans assume I’m talking about Europe. But I haven’t been and would actually like to go back to Latin America or Asia—or visit Africa—before visiting Europe. I think maybe I sensed what you wrote here.

I think you could actually take the inverse of most of this list and turn it into a great checklist for cool cities to visit.

Cultivated - Coarse

Coherent - Inscrutable

Well-ordered - Chaotic

Self-assured - Unpretentious

Clean - Grimey

Calm - Frenetic

Easeful - Antagonistic

Reliable - Surprising

Downcast - Thrilling

Get the list short enough and call it Chapin’s Razor. Like, “man I love Mexico City, New Orleans, and Beijing. The best cities are inscrutable, chaotic, grimey, frenetic, surprising, and thrilling.” I think part of the secret sauce will be figuring out when one end of the spectrum is good and when a blend is good. Like I always prefer thrilling to downcast, but really great cities blend new and old, or cultivated and coarse. It’s not a finished idea haha but your list was very insightful

Rahul Naryani's avatar

"This is not reasonable but it’s my preference." Best sentence of this post!

4 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?