Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Vincent's avatar

I had a conversation with a friend yesterday about how if you're able to see beneath the masked flailing - the people pleasing, the insecurities etc - and speak directly to the beautiful and particular individual underneath, you allow them to relax into that better version of themselves. A lot of us constantly feel the need to compensate for something, and when you talk to someone as if they're actually already whole, sometimes they'll start to unconsciously be moved to believe that too

Jacob's avatar

I'm a bit skeptical of this sort of account because it feels like you're marking your own homework: you feel like you've found some sort of deep insight into the mostly tightly shut clam in their heart's ocean, but you may just be doing the perfectly ordinary thing of jumping to conclusions.

Have you ever rigorously tested the sense(s) which you say you've developed here? Eg making specific predictions about a person's behaviour (past or future) and then verifying them, especially across unrelated contexts and situations? Checking your views about them against people who have more exposure to them? Seeing if your perception matches other (preferably disagreeable) people who claim they have the same sense?

I just know I've seen (at least something like) the ability you describe yourself having, in people who really do not have it, and it's insufferable hearing their apparently nuanced judgements and personality descriptions which are just the good old conjunction fallacy in empath's clothing. And I also know many people who remain surprising to others even after years of close relationships. So it feels off to me.

(I might be pattern-matching you to people who believe they're capable of deeper and more predictive insights than you're claiming for yourself.)

26 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?