I'm a psychologist who studies conversation, and I think this is all good advice! Extending the invitation is especially important––it boggles my mind how often those invitations seem to go un-extended in conversations, and how people blow past what's most interesting and important.
One thing I disagree with, though, is that most conversations between new acquaintances are bad. We find pretty consistently that people *expect* them to be bad, but once they have them, people report them being pretty great. For instance, in one of my studies, people talking to a stranger in the lab gave their conversations over a 5 out of 7, on average: https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2011809118.
Anyway, talking to other people is probably the single most important thing that people do, and it deserves some deep thinking. I think you're especially right that conversations are so contextual that they can't be abstracted––at least, not yet!
The #1 thing that changed my small talk game was getting a dog. I'm generally very shy, but with a dog you invariably end up talking to other dog parents, and these conversations feel easy because the dogs provide an obvious thing to talk about--you can chat about their breed, age, energy level, favorite toys and treats, etc. Now that I've had all these positive interactions with strangers, I'm less nervous about small talk in general.
Silence is brilliant. Andrew Callaghan, when he interviewed people for his gonzo Channel 5 program, would always wait a few seconds after his subject gave their answer. To break the silence, perhaps in a sort of panic, they'd follow up with a sort of second answer. This would always be more interesting than the first. Then the conversation really got going.
porous boundaries - let the other person lead but feel how my boundaries change during the convo and
go from that
try not to hyperfocus during the conversation because it takes me out of it. it's natural for me to get completely absorbed when i am talking but this isn't what i want with new people. so, i wear my hyperfocus monitor, and relax my way out of it, if i can, if i find myself doing it.
This is the best post I've ever read on having good conversations. As an extreme extrovert, I've been practicing this my whole life and never read someone who put what I discovered into words before.
Love this all, this especially stuck out to me as it's a disagreement I've had with so many —
"Some people get frustrated with small talk because the words themselves are not enlightening. But they’re focusing on the wrong thing..."
I ADORE small talk. Not cause I actually care-care that you live in Evanston, went to Boston College, or are a biracial only child raised by a single mom, but because we're opening doors to connection and conversation both in sharing facts and persona.
Thank you for this musing Sasha, so enlightening! Evernote'ing to share in my Adulting Kit and workplace workshops and to my general community at large.
Hi Sasha, I really enjoyed reading this. So much of what you said resonated with me. Human connection is also one of my favorite things. To me, it makes life so much richer and exciting. I'm also genuinely curious about a lot of things and other people. I've been experimenting how to better connect with people and I've had decent success. However, I'm always looking to improve on this skill, so I'm curious, do you have any resources you might suggest looking into (books, blogs, articles, courses, etc...) that might help to develop better conversation skills, specifically developing connection? Thanks!
Making Normal Conversations Better
I'm a psychologist who studies conversation, and I think this is all good advice! Extending the invitation is especially important––it boggles my mind how often those invitations seem to go un-extended in conversations, and how people blow past what's most interesting and important.
One thing I disagree with, though, is that most conversations between new acquaintances are bad. We find pretty consistently that people *expect* them to be bad, but once they have them, people report them being pretty great. For instance, in one of my studies, people talking to a stranger in the lab gave their conversations over a 5 out of 7, on average: https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2011809118.
In another study, some of our friends found that people expected conversations with strangers to be worse than they actually were (and they were pretty good): https://psycnet.apa.org/doiLanding?doi=10.1037%2Fa0037323
This is part of an emerging literature where we're finding that people underestimate just how well their conversations go. For instance, people tend to think that the people they meet like them less than they actually do: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/0956797618783714?casa_token=nMA1QY9X2D8AAAAA:BpJyUAPVQ-fOXijtaqrLJMM9B4532cjdWeQZrOd_8yOteV7Z1O8Ytsmbcaj3auVs_PWByhLsX97gkA
This is true also when people meet each other in groups––they think they're the least-liked of the group, on average: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S074959782030399X?casa_token=pEaqKi8bMN4AAAAA:lKP54mncTCqXEGp5aoFVxx701dobXcewa0287OwCD9hyMkCAyrfLvhFwouhU0MJVx1yvwlik4bY
And it's even true for kids: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/0956797620980754?casa_token=N7Slf_AI4ukAAAAA:eXCpTMLdXHmP69lJr3pm06fm1XNdoVT9YrUUcjIjcvN76N1j4iy2EDBGuDGYoI0HQtg5eRlygYYemA
Coming out of all this, I've also got some ideas about what makes a good conversation: https://experimentalhistory.substack.com/p/good-conversations-have-lots-of-doorknobs
Anyway, talking to other people is probably the single most important thing that people do, and it deserves some deep thinking. I think you're especially right that conversations are so contextual that they can't be abstracted––at least, not yet!
This is good/weird/specific enough that I can see it being used by some advanced AI robot to mimic human interaction.
The #1 thing that changed my small talk game was getting a dog. I'm generally very shy, but with a dog you invariably end up talking to other dog parents, and these conversations feel easy because the dogs provide an obvious thing to talk about--you can chat about their breed, age, energy level, favorite toys and treats, etc. Now that I've had all these positive interactions with strangers, I'm less nervous about small talk in general.
Silence is brilliant. Andrew Callaghan, when he interviewed people for his gonzo Channel 5 program, would always wait a few seconds after his subject gave their answer. To break the silence, perhaps in a sort of panic, they'd follow up with a sort of second answer. This would always be more interesting than the first. Then the conversation really got going.
my new goal in conversation
an intention to become relaxed and open
porous boundaries - let the other person lead but feel how my boundaries change during the convo and
go from that
try not to hyperfocus during the conversation because it takes me out of it. it's natural for me to get completely absorbed when i am talking but this isn't what i want with new people. so, i wear my hyperfocus monitor, and relax my way out of it, if i can, if i find myself doing it.
This is the best post I've ever read on having good conversations. As an extreme extrovert, I've been practicing this my whole life and never read someone who put what I discovered into words before.
Love your stuff, Sasha. The intentionality and lucidness with which you approach life is inspiring. Please keep writing :)
Really enjoyed this post, keep it up =)
👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
Love this all, this especially stuck out to me as it's a disagreement I've had with so many —
"Some people get frustrated with small talk because the words themselves are not enlightening. But they’re focusing on the wrong thing..."
I ADORE small talk. Not cause I actually care-care that you live in Evanston, went to Boston College, or are a biracial only child raised by a single mom, but because we're opening doors to connection and conversation both in sharing facts and persona.
Thank you for this musing Sasha, so enlightening! Evernote'ing to share in my Adulting Kit and workplace workshops and to my general community at large.
Hi Sasha, I really enjoyed reading this. So much of what you said resonated with me. Human connection is also one of my favorite things. To me, it makes life so much richer and exciting. I'm also genuinely curious about a lot of things and other people. I've been experimenting how to better connect with people and I've had decent success. However, I'm always looking to improve on this skill, so I'm curious, do you have any resources you might suggest looking into (books, blogs, articles, courses, etc...) that might help to develop better conversation skills, specifically developing connection? Thanks!
This is really good.